Kinetics and thermodynamics

Measure how fast a binder associates and dissociates, how tightly it binds at equilibrium, and what drives the binding. Repeat the run at several temperatures and the same chip gives enthalpy and entropy.

The question

How fast does it bind and release, and is the binding driven by enthalpy or by entropy?

Two binders with the same KD can differ in their rate constants and in how the binding energy splits into enthalpy and entropy. These differences guide which analog to develop. Very slow dissociation is a separate challenge: the baseline must stay stable for hours to see it.

The setup

Study 1: cAMP analogsFive cAMP derivatives (6-AH, 8-AHA, 8-AEA, 8-ADOA and 2-AHA-cAMP) on DNA, placed by DNA-directed immobilization (DDI) on a DNA chip. The analyte is the regulatory subunit RIα of protein kinase A (PKA-R)
AssaysSingle-cycle kinetics (SCK) at 15, 20, 25, 30 and 35 °C. For 6-AH-cAMP also multi-cycle kinetics (MCK) at 25 °C in MOPS buffer: nine PKA-R concentrations, 2.5 to 640 nM, on 16 molograms
Study 2: slow dissociationProtein A on a DNA chip, captured through the NeutrAvidin adapter and biotin. The analyte is trastuzumab (Herceptin), 156 pM to 20 nM by SCK, then 14 h of dissociation in buffer. 64 molograms

Measured result

Rate constants and affinity

Single-cycle sensorgram of PKA-R binding 6-AH-cAMP on DNA: eight association steps of rising height, each followed by dissociation, with a dashed 1:1 fit that follows the data. k_on 7.7 times 10 to the 5 per molar per second, k_off 7.6 times 10 to the minus 3 per second, K_D 10 nM.
Kinetics: PKA-R on 6-AH-cAMP on DNA, single-cycle kinetics at 25 °C with a 1:1 fit. One mologram shown; KD 10 ± 1.4 nM, mean and standard deviation of 14 fits.
Response at the end of each injection against PKA-R concentration on a log axis from 2.5 to 640 nM, with a sigmoidal fit. The half-maximal point, marked by a dashed line and labeled apparent K_D, is at 26 nM.
Affinity: the same pair in a multi-cycle run at nine concentrations. Response at the end of each 72 s injection, mean of 16 molograms, with a four-parameter logistic fit. Apparent KD 26 nM: the low concentrations had not reached steady state.

Enthalpy and entropy

Stacked horizontal bars of binding energy at 25 °C for five cAMP analogs. Enthalpy, blue, and minus T times entropy, orange, add up to the free energy. 6-AH and 8-AHA split about evenly, near minus 5 kcal per mol each. 8-AEA, 8-ADOA and 2-AHA are dominated by enthalpy, about minus 7 kcal per mol. Free energies are minus 10.9, 10.9, 10.9, 10.5 and 9.2 kcal per mol.
Binding energy of PKA-R to five cAMP analogs at 25 °C, from van 't Hoff analysis of single-cycle KD at 15 to 35 °C. ΔH (blue) and −TΔS (orange), in kcal/mol; the reported ΔG on the right.

The figure comes from a van 't Hoff analysis. Each temperature gives one KD. Plot ln KD against 1/T: the slope gives ΔH and the intercept gives ΔS. The lab below runs that series for an enthalpy and an entropy that you set.

Van 't Hoff plot

Set ΔH and ΔS, then press Play. At each temperature a single-cycle run gives KD, and a point drops on both plots. The two presets have the same ΔG at 25 °C, so the same KD, but a different split into ΔH and −TΔS.

Sign convention: ΔG = ΔH − TΔS = RT ln KD, with KD in M. A negative ΔG means binding. The lab sets the heat capacity change ΔCp to zero. Then ΔH and ΔS stay constant, and the van 't Hoff plot is a straight line with slope ΔH/R. If ΔH is negative, KD rises with temperature.

The series runs from 15 to 45 °C: the stage heater reaches 45 °C, and temperatures below room temperature need an external cooling device. Each run uses five 3-fold steps from KD/9 at 25 °C. The lab holds kon at the measured 7.7 × 105 M−1s−1, and only koff follows KD. In a real series, kon also changes with temperature.

Picomolar apparent affinity, 14 hours of dissociation

Top: a single-cycle sensorgram over 15 hours. Eight association steps in the first 45 minutes, a fast drop in the first hour of dissociation, then a nearly flat dissociation over 13 hours, with a dashed 1:1 fit. Bottom: rate map of 64 molograms, k_off from 10 to the minus 7 to 10 to the minus 5 per second, k_on near 10 to the 6, median K_D 2.5 pM.
Trastuzumab on Protein A. Top: one mologram, normalized response. Single-cycle kinetics from 156 pM to 20 nM, then 14 h of dissociation, with a 1:1 fit (apparent KD 1.2 pM). Bottom: rate constants of all 64 molograms; one koff below 1.2 × 10−7 s−1 is drawn at that value.

How to read it

Why it works

Ridges and grooves see the same buffer and the same temperature, so changes that act on both cancel. A temperature ramp from 25 to 43 °C moves the refractometric readout MD by thousands of pg/mm² while coherent mass density stays flat. The same cancellation lets you compare runs at different temperatures. The same cancellation keeps the baseline stable over the hours a slow dissociation needs.

Read more: the measured temperature ramp, baseline noise and drift, and reading and fitting sensorgrams.

More